I'm not sure what this
particular board's policy is on slash, but I'm a fan myself, and I've gathered
that this particular story is a "classic" of the Hanson/Moffatts
sub-genre (or the Taylor/Scott genre, to be more specific), so I went ahead and
checked it out. Boy, am I glad I did!
First off, let me say that I know ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about the Moffatts.
Seriously. (It took me all of 5 chapters to figure out there were four of them.)
So I can't say whether those character depictions were accurate or not. Still,
all the characters in the story were fairly well-drawn, although not the best
I've seen.
The best thing about the story as a whole is the way the love story is done.
I've read a good chunk of slashy stories in my day, but a lot of the time
(sadly) they either deteriorate into smut, or have a decent plotline but fudge
the more intimate scenes by turning them into some sort of grotesque anatomy
lesson. (Too many gorey details, in other words.) Neither of those things
happens here. It's plenty graphic, but tastefully done, which is what sets it
apart as an actual love story, and not something else.
There's also a wonderfully creepy sideplot involving some photographs and
semi-threatening messages that come to both Taylor and Scott through the mail. I
won't give anything away, but I will say it makes for a rather intriguing
mystery that's just a little bit spookier than your average "What if
somebody finds out?" plotline.
There were a couple things that irked me quite a bit. First: shifting
perspectives. I'll allow that there's nothing wrong with showing the same story
from more than one POV - plenty of highly respected, published authors do it all
the time - but what I'm talking about here is the tendency to switch POVs in the
middle of scene, sometimes in the middle of love scene even, and marking the
shift with nothing but a name in italics above the next paragraph to tell you
who "I" is. This seems to happen a lot in fanfic, particularly in
short stories, but I have never liked it. I can read through it most of time,
because it just happens so often, but the effect is just plain jarring. It
interrupts the flow of the narrative, and I think it chips away at the quality
of the story.
The other thing that bugged me, slightly less than the perspective shifts, was
the Zac/Dave story. It was okay, but it felt tacked-on somehow, like there was
just too much going on in the same story. This goes along with the perspective
shifts, I think - the author's trying to be in too many places at once, and it
just gets exhausting after awhile.
That said, it's still a great story (if you're into slash at all - if not, just
stay away, because it's not subtle in the slightest). It is unfinished, which is
horribly disappointing when you finally reach chapter 40, but a great read
nonetheless. Oh, and here's the link, since I forgot about including one last
time: http://www.hansonfiction.com/aspen